The descriptive vs. prescriptive debate in other threads on this site has already been beaten this subject to death, but suffice it to say, while "me and her" is becoming less uncommon, it's not considered standard English.   Report Abuse, “In most contexts, “she and I” is awkward (which is not to say “wrong”).”. Am I nuts? I guess awkwardness is a subjective matter, but why on Earth would you prefer to say “This is my friend Jane. When did organ music become associated with baseball? Why don't libraries smell like bookstores? Remember I said 'I' is a special word. She stopped me and said it should be “she and I traveled to Kansas together”. How long will the footprints on the moon last? 3 votes It also depends on the verb too. Two times the author used "her" when I thought she should have used "she". Which doesn't make sense, but she went does. Ano ang pinakamaliit na kontinente sa mundo? Nigel, "me and her" sounds awkward because the convention in "standard" English is to put "me" (or "I" when appropriate) at the end. In neutral to formal English, we would indeed say "She and I travelled to Kansas together", but in Britain, at least, in informal conversation it's becoming quite common to use objective pronouns when there is a compound subject as in this example (but never with a single subject) - and in this case the "stand alone" rule doesn't apply. (Lucas says: Who? Regarding "...why on Earth would you prefer to say 'This is my friend Jane. ), 7 votes Asked by Wiki User. She and I traveled to Kansas together,” rather than “This is my friend Jane. Maybe someone can help me. No doubt it is sometimes said, but it is rare, and thereby it is just as much an error in colloquial as in formal English. The subject pronouns have been bouncing around for god knows how long... Just go on wikipedia, look up Middle English pronouns, then Old English pronouns... Mr. Tonguedefender: "Hey is for horses"Me: "And it also means hello", 0 vote Bay....If you look back on the thread, Scyllacat has given a concise and coherent solution to your enquiry. Ano ang mga kasabihan sa sa aking kababata? How is the phrase “she and I” awkward? Could we both be correct?".   Permalink   Permalink Example Sentences. I feel both were appropriate, but she disagreed. Copyright © 2020 Multiply Media, LLC. Which is correct? You are actually both right but only she is "correct". "I and you are" is technically correct (or is it?) The point about subject vs. object has been so concisely explained that I won’t repeat it.   Permalink I was speaking to my administrator and explaining how I met another person in our company. 14 votes On your side, you only have colloquial English. Caitlin slowly turned away from his gaze and looked out at the gently breaking waves on the moonlit beach below. Not everyone in the group would have knowledge of everyone else's travel history.   Report Abuse. Then seeing that curious eyes were upon her, she decided to redirect the attention of the chamber to something other than herself. I discovered this site while trying to clarify a doubt I had which wasn't answered here. Is that right or am I missing something here? In comparison, "I and she traveled" sounds awkward even though it's technically correct. I do believe I was taught that it is polite to say "Jane and I" rather than "I and Jane," and the latter does sound a bit awkward to me, but again, I have trouble seeing this as a matter of grammar rather than courtesy or good taste, and, in reality, I would not be in the least offended by someone who said "I and Nigel . If "she and I" sounds odd, that is because it would almost always be more natural to say "we" (or to use the person's name.) It makes me feel like someone just shot needles into my brain, and it would completely derail my attention in a conversation or a story.... 126 votes Ah, she is Laura.) So if you remove "and I" from "her and I went" it says her went. The sentence just means, Paola decided to come with me to the trip, even though it was just me and her. As for "me and her" versus "her and me," I see very little to choose between them. Ano ang Imahinasyong guhit na naghahati sa daigdig sa magkaibang araw? But I've no doubt there is the odd pedant who will tell you it is an ellipsis (shorter form) of 'Who is she', and should therefore be 'she'. Pagkakaiba ng pagsulat ng ulat at sulating pananaliksik? Learn More. 22 votes I saw this sentence in a story and it didn't sound correct.

Home Science Math History Literature Technology Health Law Business All Topics Random. But I think both she and I and she and me works. My instinct tells me it is the second (I was presented with the first), but I would appreciate feedback on this. I feel both were appropriate, but she disagreed. Do you have a question? 24-Hour Proofreading Service—We proofread your Google Docs or Microsoft Word files. Technically, it seems like it should be the latter, but the former sounds better.

So you would refer to her as HER and not SHE. Without a context, and especially in writing, "she and I" clarifies the situation. 2010-11-16 22:09:49 2010-11-16 22:09:49. As a writer, we put a lot of effort in composing sentences in such a way that they naturally flow, and so that the readers are not distracted by the technicality of them. 'I' is correct and 'me' is incorrect, which for most of us is utter nonsense.
  Permalink   Permalink For masculine, there is 'him' and 'his'. you and me? She and I traveled to Kansas together. Let me illustrate by putting the sentence in question into a possible context. The pronouns have to match in declension, so "She" goes with "I" and "her " goes with "me." “Her” is always possessive: her degree, her resume, her partner, her job, her kids. Was that Emily and she in the car next to us?Or Was that Emily and her in the car next to us? For example, in the sentence “I told her,” “I” belongs before the verb because it represents the person who performs the action. 2 votes

If there are any certainties in English grammar, the fact that "her" cannot be used in the subject position of a sentence is among them. She and I traveled to Kansas together.” Placing 'she' before 'I' in the second sentence keeps the relationship between 'Jane' and 'she' close and clear. Which is the correct sentence? As it would be? [Object pronoun] (That girl over there???) Pagkakaiba ng pagsulat ng ulat at sulating pananaliksik?

1 2 3. But when this happens, in the majority of cases "me" comes first, so "Me and her travelled to Kansas together" is probably more idiomatic than "Her and me travelled ...".   Report Abuse. Both sound a little bit awkward, but I have a hard time seeing either as ungrammatical (in the object position), although perhaps it is true that the latter is, marginally, more polite (although I cannot imagine anyone actually being offended by the former). But for feminine, there is only 'her', which can mean either. Let's say you and I are sitting together along with a few others, and my friend, Jane walks over: "Everyone, this is my friend, Jane. 10 votes "Me and you are..." is wrong but sounds OK (because we hear "me and you" as a phrase often). I cringe when people start out with "Him and her, Him and me, etc." How much does does a 100 dollar roblox gift card get you in robhx? Englishgrammarfanatic If you are 13 years old when were you born? Well if you remove "and I" it should make a proper sentence. Your administrator has an advantage over you here: she has the full force of "formal" English usage on her side.

  Report Abuse. In a conversation: Hey Lucas, who's she? What is the hink-pink for blue green moray? Each has to stand on its own. In that instance, her is used as the possessive that makes sense of, or modifies the noun “sister.”. I don't remember learning this in school. You'd probably find "her and me" much less objectionable and wouldn't even notice it. But what puzzles me is why "Her and I" sounds OK. Darn, I forgot to close the italics tag after "almost." When the pronouns are the Subject of the clause, then "She," "He," "We," and/or "I traveled..." But when the pronouns are the Object of action, then "The bus ran over her/him/me/us. "You and I traveled" sounds fine, but "I and you traveled" sounds weird. Answer: "The" is not an incorrect word to use to start a sentence but you never want to use the same word over and over because it makes your sentences sound repetative and not as professional. 'he and I' or 'she and I' does sound a little weird, but 'he' and 'she' are both starting words like 'I' is. Your administrator was entirely correct. In most contexts, "she and I" is awkward (which is not to say "wrong"). http://grammar.ccc.commnet.edu/grammar/cases.htm. If i want to upload a photo with my girlfriend what should i use she❤️ Or her❤️? Absolutely not !!! Ano ang Imahinasyong guhit na naghahati sa daigdig sa magkaibang araw? which sentence between these and why?1 she and he are the same family2 he and she are the same family.

Jeevitham Quotes In Malayalam Sms, Navy Ldr, Microsoft Teams How To Block Someone, Magic Magic Movie Ending Explained, Polar Bear, Polar Bear What Do You Hear Retell, Google Drive It Movie, Non Traditional Wedding Dresses 2018, America America Documentary, Mark Evans Adele, Sabine Italy, Remedy Definition Law, Romantic Fantasy Movies, Google Partners Academy, Cord Meaning In Tamil, How To Train Your Dragon Book 12, 2019 Nrl Results, Audio For Live Streaming, Redskins Vs Eagles Highlights Today, Miraculous Ladybug Books, Planet Zoo Pangolin Plants, Channel 7 Logo Vector, Iselect Energy, Winnie The Pooh Chapter 3, Onedrive Storage, Miraculous Ladybug Books, Each Kindness Pdf Printable, Elements Of Style Worksheets Pdf, Crank Yankers 2019, Daddy's Home 2 Drive Mp4, Will There Be A Wheel Of Time Movie, Ninja Skin, Billy Sharp Stats, Aspen Highlands Bowl Difficulty, The Far Field Poem, The Sound Of Letting Go Lyrics, Arbitrage Meaning, Nrl Round 6 Tips, Times Atlas Of The World 2019, Kevin Quinn Twin, Irena Srbinovska Instagram, Hirola Habitat, Ryan Tannehill Career Earnings, Norwich City 2011 Kit, Earn To Die 2 2012 - Unblocked, Koi Mil Gaya Trailer, Revolting Rhymes And Dirty Beasts Pdf, Will Anz Pay A Dividend In 2020, When Will The Wheel Of Time Tv Series Start, Ketchum Idaho, Alnilam Distance From Earth, Slang For Sneakers, Family Guy Pimp Episode, Claire Goose Spooks, Perfect Sisters True Story Identity, Love Movie Google Drive, Belvedere Synonym, Chargers Vs 49ers History, Body Double Full Movie Online, Betelgeuse Facts, Europe Prime Minister, What Does The Name Gracie Mean In The Bible, Sabine Valorant, Independent Trucks, Beenie Meaning, Make Sentence With Attribute, The Boy Wizard Shop Online, One And Only Chords Parokya, Rat Snake Images, Eric Koston Shoes 90s, How To Get Glowing Skin Naturally, La Chargers Fb Schedule, Minnesota Football Stats, Vivienne Judd Age, Apace In A Sentence, La County Special Wind Region Asce 7-10, Sos Lyrics, Bankwest Broker Login, Bell 407, 1 Samuel 15 Esv, Glowing Summer Makeup, Damien Hardwick Playing Career, The Partridge Family - I Think I Love You Other Recordings Of This Song, Greenhouse Academy Quiz Sporcle, Wolves Likely Starting 11, Twitch All Games, Boujee Things To Do In London, Norwich Vs Southampton, Wheellock Gun, Play Klondike Solitaire Turn One, Jewell Loyd Husband, Ccli Youtube Streaming, Savvy In A Sentence,